The element of a picture within a picture is recurring in Vermeer’s artwork. Generally speaking, many artists used the picture presented in the background as a way to relate to the central theme of the painting. In The Concert, there are two painting hanging in on the back wall behind the players. On the left side hangs a pastoral landscape painting that relates to the landscape painted on the lid of the harpsichord. The second painting on the right side is Dirck van Baburen’s The Procuress (1622). Baburen was an important figure of the Utrecht Caravaggisti, a group of Baroque artists influenced by the art of Caravaggio, that were mainly based in the Dutch city of Utrecht. The Procuress depicts a brothel scene, a popular subject in Dutch genre painting. Baburen’s painting is also a composition of three figures: the prostitute, the customer and the procuress. The scene in The Procuress offers a thematic contrast to Vermeer’s ensemble. While in Baburen’s painting music is associated with illicit love, Vermeer’s musical trio embodies the ideals of harmony and moderation. The Procuress also appears in the background of another painting by Vermeer, A young woman seated at a virginal (ca.1670-1672), which was painted approximately six years after The Concert. There are at least three versions of Baburen’s painting, one of which belonged to Vermeer’s mother in-law, Maria Thins, who owned a collection of art produced by Utrecht Caravaggisti painters.
The first documentation of The Concert was only in 1780. The painting was acquired in 1892 by art patron and collector, Isabella Stewart Gardner at the auction of Théophile Thoré-Bürger collection. Thoré-Bürger was a French art critic and journalist, who played a key role in the rediscovery of the works of Jan Vermeer in the 19th century. The Concert was one of the first Vermeer’s to be brought to the United States, and was exhibited in the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in Boston. In 1990, The Concert was one of thirteen artworks stolen from the museum, and it has yet to be recovered.